Nov 24, 2025
Boost guest retention with a well-designed restaurant ordering experience
Your website is probably the first time most people interact with your restaurant. And if it's clunky, slow, or confusing? They're gone before they even see your menu.
This matters more than ever. Independent restaurants are competing with chains that have massive marketing budgets and slick digital experiences. Your website needs to work as hard as you do—turning browsers into diners and one-time visitors into regulars.
The good news? You don't need a Fortune 500 budget to create a website that converts. You just need to understand what your customers are looking for and make it easy for them to find it.
Look, people make snap judgments. If your site takes forever to load or they can't figure out how to see your menu, they're not going to give you the benefit of the doubt. They'll just hit the back button and try the place down the street.
A good website does a few things really well:
When people have a smooth experience on your site, they're more likely to actually show up. And they're definitely more likely to tell their friends about you.
Think about the path someone takes from "I'm hungry" to sitting at one of your tables. They're probably:
Each of these steps is an opportunity to either help them along or lose them completely.
The restaurants that win are the ones that make this journey brain-dead simple. Clear menu with good photos? Check. Easy way to order or book? Check. Contact info that doesn't require a treasure hunt? Check.
If you're using something like Peppr's platform, a lot of this gets handled automatically—and you keep your money instead of paying 20% to DoorDash.
Strip away all the fancy design talk, and here's what actually makes a difference:
Navigation that makes sense – People should never wonder where to click. If your menu structure requires a flowchart to understand, you've overcomplicated it.
Real photos of your food – Not stock images. Not overly filtered Instagram shots. Just good, honest photos of what you're serving. If you can't afford a professional photographer, learn some basic food photography techniques and DIY it.
Your story – Why did you open this restaurant? What makes your approach different? People want to know there are actual humans behind the business.
Consistent branding – Your website should feel like your restaurant. If you run a laid-back taco spot, don't make your site look like a fine dining establishment.
The design should get out of the way and let people do what they came to do.
Your menu page is probably getting more traffic than any other page on your site. Don't waste that opportunity.
Here's what works:
If someone lands on your menu page and can't quickly figure out if you have what they're craving, they're bouncing. Make it scannable, make it visual, make it helpful.
More than half your traffic is coming from phones. If your site doesn't work well on mobile, you're actively turning away customers.
This means:
Google also prioritizes mobile-friendly sites in search results, so this isn't just about user experience—it's about being found in the first place.
Every page should have a clear next step. What do you want people to do? Order food? Book a table? Sign up for your email list?
Don't make them work for it:
Here's the thing about third-party delivery apps: they're expensive. You're paying 15-30% in commissions. If you can drive orders through your own site using a commission-free system like Peppr, you keep that money. That adds up fast.
About a quarter of adults have some type of disability. If your site isn't accessible, you're excluding a lot of potential customers.
This isn't complicated:
This is both the right thing to do and good for business. Plus, accessibility is increasingly required by law.
Words only go so far. People want to see what they're getting into.
Quality visuals do a few things:
You don't need a Hollywood production. Behind-the-scenes shots, your chef talking about a signature dish, even well-lit photos of your dining room—all of this helps people decide if your restaurant is right for them.
And don't underestimate user-generated content. When actual customers post photos of your food (with permission), that's more powerful than anything you could create yourself.
Reviews matter. A lot. People trust other diners more than they trust you.
Feature your best reviews somewhere prominent on your site. Pull in ratings from Google, Yelp, or other platforms. Show real testimonials with names and, if possible, photos.
Also, make sure your site is secure. Use HTTPS (you'll see the padlock in the browser). Display any relevant security badges. Be transparent about your policies.
When people see that others have had good experiences and that you take their data seriously, they're much more likely to place an order or make a reservation.
Your website isn't something you build once and forget about. It needs regular attention.
Use Google Analytics to see where people are dropping off. Which pages get the most traffic? Where do people leave? What buttons aren't getting clicked?
Ask your customers for feedback. Put a simple survey on your site or include a question in your post-order emails.
Test different approaches. Try a different CTA button color. Rearrange your menu categories. See what works better.
Keep your content fresh. Update your menu. Add new photos. Write about seasonal specials or new dishes.
If you're using Peppr's platform, a lot of this analysis is built in, so you can see what's working without needing to become a data analyst.
Your website should work like a good server: anticipate what people need, make their experience smooth, and give them a reason to come back.
Focus on the fundamentals—fast loading, mobile-friendly, easy navigation, clear CTAs, good photos. Get those right before you worry about anything fancy.
The restaurants that treat their website as a core part of their business (not an afterthought) are the ones that consistently fill seats and drive online orders.
Check out how Peppr can help you create a better website experience while eliminating commission fees on online orders. More money stays in your pocket, and your customers get a smoother experience. That's the kind of win-win that actually matters.
Your website is probably the first time most people interact with your restaurant. And if it's clunky, slow, or confusing? They're gone before they even see your menu.
This matters more than ever. Independent restaurants are competing with chains that have massive marketing budgets and slick digital experiences. Your website needs to work as hard as you do—turning browsers into diners and one-time visitors into regulars.
The good news? You don't need a Fortune 500 budget to create a website that converts. You just need to understand what your customers are looking for and make it easy for them to find it.
Look, people make snap judgments. If your site takes forever to load or they can't figure out how to see your menu, they're not going to give you the benefit of the doubt. They'll just hit the back button and try the place down the street.
A good website does a few things really well:
When people have a smooth experience on your site, they're more likely to actually show up. And they're definitely more likely to tell their friends about you.
Think about the path someone takes from "I'm hungry" to sitting at one of your tables. They're probably:
Each of these steps is an opportunity to either help them along or lose them completely.
The restaurants that win are the ones that make this journey brain-dead simple. Clear menu with good photos? Check. Easy way to order or book? Check. Contact info that doesn't require a treasure hunt? Check.
If you're using something like Peppr's platform, a lot of this gets handled automatically—and you keep your money instead of paying 20% to DoorDash.
Strip away all the fancy design talk, and here's what actually makes a difference:
Navigation that makes sense – People should never wonder where to click. If your menu structure requires a flowchart to understand, you've overcomplicated it.
Real photos of your food – Not stock images. Not overly filtered Instagram shots. Just good, honest photos of what you're serving. If you can't afford a professional photographer, learn some basic food photography techniques and DIY it.
Your story – Why did you open this restaurant? What makes your approach different? People want to know there are actual humans behind the business.
Consistent branding – Your website should feel like your restaurant. If you run a laid-back taco spot, don't make your site look like a fine dining establishment.
The design should get out of the way and let people do what they came to do.
Your menu page is probably getting more traffic than any other page on your site. Don't waste that opportunity.
Here's what works:
If someone lands on your menu page and can't quickly figure out if you have what they're craving, they're bouncing. Make it scannable, make it visual, make it helpful.
More than half your traffic is coming from phones. If your site doesn't work well on mobile, you're actively turning away customers.
This means:
Google also prioritizes mobile-friendly sites in search results, so this isn't just about user experience—it's about being found in the first place.
Every page should have a clear next step. What do you want people to do? Order food? Book a table? Sign up for your email list?
Don't make them work for it:
Here's the thing about third-party delivery apps: they're expensive. You're paying 15-30% in commissions. If you can drive orders through your own site using a commission-free system like Peppr, you keep that money. That adds up fast.
About a quarter of adults have some type of disability. If your site isn't accessible, you're excluding a lot of potential customers.
This isn't complicated:
This is both the right thing to do and good for business. Plus, accessibility is increasingly required by law.
Words only go so far. People want to see what they're getting into.
Quality visuals do a few things:
You don't need a Hollywood production. Behind-the-scenes shots, your chef talking about a signature dish, even well-lit photos of your dining room—all of this helps people decide if your restaurant is right for them.
And don't underestimate user-generated content. When actual customers post photos of your food (with permission), that's more powerful than anything you could create yourself.
Reviews matter. A lot. People trust other diners more than they trust you.
Feature your best reviews somewhere prominent on your site. Pull in ratings from Google, Yelp, or other platforms. Show real testimonials with names and, if possible, photos.
Also, make sure your site is secure. Use HTTPS (you'll see the padlock in the browser). Display any relevant security badges. Be transparent about your policies.
When people see that others have had good experiences and that you take their data seriously, they're much more likely to place an order or make a reservation.
Your website isn't something you build once and forget about. It needs regular attention.
Use Google Analytics to see where people are dropping off. Which pages get the most traffic? Where do people leave? What buttons aren't getting clicked?
Ask your customers for feedback. Put a simple survey on your site or include a question in your post-order emails.
Test different approaches. Try a different CTA button color. Rearrange your menu categories. See what works better.
Keep your content fresh. Update your menu. Add new photos. Write about seasonal specials or new dishes.
If you're using Peppr's platform, a lot of this analysis is built in, so you can see what's working without needing to become a data analyst.
Your website should work like a good server: anticipate what people need, make their experience smooth, and give them a reason to come back.
Focus on the fundamentals—fast loading, mobile-friendly, easy navigation, clear CTAs, good photos. Get those right before you worry about anything fancy.
The restaurants that treat their website as a core part of their business (not an afterthought) are the ones that consistently fill seats and drive online orders.
Check out how Peppr can help you create a better website experience while eliminating commission fees on online orders. More money stays in your pocket, and your customers get a smoother experience. That's the kind of win-win that actually matters.
.avif){kind=logo}
